Curd is the Word: Packers Camp Buzz Begins
Camp week 1 practices are in the books
By GregMeinholz

The bikes lined up outside Lambeau Field once again this week. Players made dreams come true just by simply making their way to and from practice and being visible for those kids to see up close and in person. Many of us older Packer fans are excited to see our favorite team get back to work as we look forward to cheering them on each week until hopefully February. But for many of these kids, camp is a memory that will last them a lifetime. That's what makes Packers Training Camp so special. Many of them won't get to a game this season, so this is it. And the Packers do it like no other.
I've been to Training Camp practices at least once a year for the last decade and a half, and you can always feel the excitement around you. To someone who doesn't understand, they may sit in the bleachers of Ray Nitschke Field and think it's silly that fans are applauding and hollering for catches by receivers just running individual routes. Outside of fans just being passionate, this could be the only time some of those fans will see that in person this season, so they want the players to hear their support. And judging by the mix of players getting the crowd riled up during practice, they want to hear it from them, too.
As usual, we have our stand-outs from Training Camp week 1 and a few things to discuss, so let's get into it.
Brandon McManus
Let's get this one out of the way right away. Last year, we suffered through Anders Carlson and Greg Joseph battling it out for the open kicker position in camp. In each practice, there would be a "winner" of the kicker battle. But that was often questionable, as one kicker would go 3/5 and the other 2/5. So, in reality, we were all losers. We won't suffer through the rest of the details before Brandon McManus saved our kicking game, and so far, McManus is 24/24 in field goal attempts through three camp practices. What a change a year makes, and I can't emphasize enough how good it feels not to have to discuss a kicking competition.
Marshawn Lloyd
Last year around this time, the thought was that Marshawn Lloyd might give AJ Dillon a run for his money to be RB2 behind Josh Jacobs. Dillon never played a down last season, so that left the job all to Lloyd, right? Well, Lloyd himself struggled with injury after a strong camp and barely touched the field as well. This year, Lloyd seems to be back with a vengeance. He's been practically glued to Josh Jacobs' side, which is not a surprise given the excitement Jacobs has for Lloyd's return. The second-year player is soaking up all he can from the vet so he can come out screaming in 2025.
Lloyd showed off the burst he has when changing direction and turning upfield with several outside runs this week. One of the highlights was when Lloyd bounced outside, turning what could've been a minimal play into a possible 20-yard run. Of course, we're not in pads yet and not tackling, so that is purely speculative, but it's clear Lloyd isn't just here to get through camp and see what happens; he's here to claim his spot on gameday.
Matthew Golden & Savion Williams
The day 1 and day 2 rookie receivers are turning heads already in training camp.
Golden is already showing how he can be a weapon anywhere on the field. He's shown some good reps coming down with the ball easily with two feet in the end zone, and we also got a peek at him taking a jet sweep on Friday, which could be an interesting feature in 2025, having so many receivers capable of making plays in that situation. Perhaps one of the best reps I got to see a highlight of was when he ran a short return route and noticed that Jordan Love was under pressure, so he turned upfield a bit and was hit by Love for what would've been at least a 20+ yard gain. Golden is showing some great on-field awareness to bail out his QB and make a play early on.
Savion Williams also showed some good flashes, including a leaping one-handed catch in the end zone. It is of note that Williams did not practice on Friday due to a concussion. The cause is not yet known, nor how long he will be out.

Carrington Valentine and Nate Hobbs
On to the defense. With the departure of Jaire Alexander, of course, everyone's a little nervous about the corner position. But Carrington Valentine and Nate Hobbs made a bit of a statement in camp this week that they will not be hearing it.
Valentine has been very sticky in coverage, staying on receivers regardless of the route. He's come up with two INTs in camp so far, which one was off a tipped Malik Willis pass and the other was due to the receiver, Julian Hicks, falling, but in Valentine's eyes, those will likely be just excuses, and nonetheless, a pick is a pick. He nearly had a third on a comeback route against Matthew Golden, but came up just short. Valentine is making a big case for a starting job already this summer.
Hobbs has been showing that he comes with intensity every day and has several pass breakups to his credit in camp so far, including a big one against Dontayvion Wicks, where he may have gotten a little overzealous with a no-pads hit to Wicks, earning him a talking-to from Matt LaFleur but regardless, Hobbs looks like he could be fun to watch.
Edgerrin Cooper
Edge Cooper is doing Edge Cooper things. That's all there is to say. Cooper is picking up where he left off last season, with many moments where he's burst through the line for what would be a tackle for loss in the running game. This could be the year Edgerrin Cooper becomes a star in the NFL.
Isaiah Simmons
The former 2020 eighth overall pick is showing why he was just that. His size and speed are already on display in camp so far, as he's gotten some reps in the base defense on the strong side in the absence of Quay Walker. He's been all over the place, his top highlight so far being a tipped Malik Willis pass that was intercepted by Carrington Valentine. We've been saying it all along that if Simmons' full potential can be unlocked, he'll be a huge addition to this defense.
Mark Murphy
Last but not least, we have Mark Murphy serving his final day as President and CEO of the Packers on Friday. Murphy cemented his legacy in Green Bay with all the stadium and Packers facility additions he oversaw, as well as the TitleTown creation. His swan song was the NFL Draft in Green Bay, and he nailed every bit of it. During Training Camp last year, I chased down Mark in the Lambeau Parking lot with my son to have him sign my son's football, that's gathered quite a roster of signatures over the last four seasons, and he was very gracious with us and I can't thank him enough for that and everything he's done for the Green Bay Packers in his tenure. Thanks, Mark, enjoy your well-earned retirement.
PLEASE SUBSCRIBE TO OUR CHEESEHEAD NATION WEEKLY NEWSLETTER HERE.
__________________________
Greg Meinholz is a lifelong devoted Packer fan. A contributor to CheeseheadTV as well as PackersTalk. Follow him on Twitter @gmeinholz and Bluesky @gmeinholz.bsky.social for Packers commentary, random humor, beer endorsements, and occasional Star Wars and Marvel ramblings.
__________________________




Comments (12)
LLCHESTY
July 27, 2025 at 06:25 am
From what I've heard on local radio(long commute) Wicks has been impressive. His only drop probably would have been an interference call in a game but otherwise he's been catching clearly according to Wilde et al.
Coldworld
July 27, 2025 at 10:35 am
It’s been good to see, but let’s see what happens when catches and routes are contested. So far the WRs have a super advantage. Wicks is a bigger guy—it usually favors slot types and scat backs most, but still.
Valentine might have been called on his second interception since contact before the catch caused Hicks to hit the turf (took his feet out) though seemingly accidental. The point is, he’s in position regularly, which is all one can hope for in shorts. However, we know he can cover, but to advance he has to be more physical, generally and as a tackler. That test has yet to commence. Melton’s positioning has been surprisingly good. He’s is looking like a genuine roster contender, which the absence of that might well have rendered extremely unlikely.
Pads go on soon and the more contact time we get, the more real the test is for everyone. If Simmons can hit as well as he’s been covering, we might have to rethink how to get him more snaps (as a true linebacker) if Walker and Cooper are healthy. Williams at S has looked more like he did early last year: instinctive. That too is exciting.
LLCHESTY
July 27, 2025 at 12:49 pm
They probably wouldn't do it since they want to resign him but I'd have no problem substituting Simmons for Walker on passing downs. Walker's coverage has slipped since a decent rookie year. If Simmons is really good in coverage maybe they'll feel comfortable playing more base on 1st downs.
GregC
July 27, 2025 at 04:06 pm
You are quick on the trigger to replace the player who wears the dot for our defense. Remember, Simmons was traded from the Cardinals to the Giants two years ago for a 7th round draft pick, which tells you what the Cardinals thought of him, then the Giants were also unable to find a way to use him on defense and simply released him. I would love to see him suddenly become a good NFL player in year six, but it will take more than three unpadded practices to convince me that he's ready to do so.
LLCHESTY
July 27, 2025 at 06:04 pm
I'm quick to want to replace him on passing downs IF Simmons is better in coverage. Walker is heading the wrong way in coverage; he was above average as a rookie, average his 2nd year and below average last year. Great athlete but his instincts are lacking at a instinctive position, I'm not sure why they are so eager to resign him. I'd wait to see how he does this year. I also don't think you want to be paying two off ball LBs big money down the road so if they do resign him I hope it's something they can easily get out of after two years.
Oppy
July 28, 2025 at 12:49 am
I don't know if Simmons is better at pass coverage, but I do know over the course of his career, QBs average above 100 passer rating when targeting Simmons' coverage.. and the last two seasons it was 112-ish.
norcaljoe
July 31, 2025 at 07:29 am
I know it's TC, but there are a lot of positive performances going on - Golden, Wicks, VanNess, McManus, Lloyd. There's a lot to like right now. And that's a lot better than the alternative.
Guam
July 27, 2025 at 07:23 am
Without pads it is always the "little" guys that get the attention and so it has been during the first week of practice. I want to see what happens on the OL and DL when the pads are on. The game changes when the hitting starts.
I am a little concerned about the back injuries to Jenkins and Banks. Back injuries can be fluky and while the team is saying they are minor I hope they don't turn into something more. The depth on the O-line could evaporate quickly if Jenkins and Banks are injured for any length of time.
Happy trails Mark Murphy. Enjoy your retirement, you earned it!
Coldworld
July 27, 2025 at 10:38 am
Back injuries can be nothing or almost impossible to shed. Some can be played through, but not particularly well typically. Like you, I always have concerns. Of course we are told as little as possible, so there’s really nothing concrete there to support that concern at the individual level.
Guam
July 27, 2025 at 04:17 pm
What's with the down votes? Perfectly reasonable response to my comment.
norcaljoe
July 31, 2025 at 07:32 am
Thanks for mentioning the nature of the injuries to Jenkins and Banks. I don't give a whole lot of significance to what comes out of TC - it is good to hear that most players are doing very well. But injuries are a cloud over every team. So yeah, let's hope this is caution prevailing and the injuries are short term.
norcaljoe
July 31, 2025 at 07:26 am
That was a nice comment on Murphy. I haven't paid a lot of attention to him because he always likes to talk more than anyone else at pressers, and that's irritating. That aside and as you note, he has made Lambeau and Green Bay a year-round destination, something I would have thought impossible.
He's done a great job as president and I hope he has a long and enjoyable retirement. I expect Policy will continue this tradition of leadership excellence in GB.